By: 21 March 2018
Clyde & Co: The truth about fundamental dishonesty

As insurers get to grips with the implications of Section 57’s definition of fundamental dishonesty, Clyde & Co’s Damian Rourke shows how the legislation can halt exaggerated third-party claims early

Three years ago, new legislation in England and Wales filled a gap that has existed in third-party personal injury claims. In a first-party claim, the duty of utmost good faith has always meant that, in the event of a claimant behaving dishonestly, the claim could be dismissed. But in third-party claims, the potential to respond in this way did not exist—until Section 57 of the Criminal Justice and Courts Act (CJCA) 2015 introduced the concept of fundamental dishonesty. This legislation handed insurers a new weapon in the battle against dishonest claimants, but in the three years since its introduction, relatively few have sought to use it.

Until recently, the successful use of Section 57 to dismiss cases has generally been isolated to lower value claims. However, in light of further judicial guidance, defendants and their insurers are becoming increasingly confident in using these provisions. As a result, larger value claims are now finding their way before the courts, with successes for defendants being reported.

How section 57 differs from QOCS

The difference between a finding of fundamental dishonesty under the qualified one-way costs shifting (QOCS) regime and that under Section 57 of the CJCA is important. Broadly speaking, QOCS fundamental dishonesty under CPR 44.16 can be summarised as the claimant unsuccessfully bringing a fraudulent claim—usually entirely fraudulent—and losing QOCS protection as a consequence. Section 57 fundamental dishonesty is different. It addresses those claimants who dishonestly exaggerate a genuine claim, causing that claim, including genuine heads of loss, to be dismissed.

The decision in LOCOG v Sinfield [2018] EWHC 51 (QB) provides the most recent guidance for what conduct constitutes fundamental dishonesty under Section 57. In this case, the claimant had been injured as a volunteer worker at the 2012 Olympic Games. His claim included the cost of employing a gardener, which he asserted was necessary as a result of his injuries. However, during the trial, it became clear that the claimant had employed a gardener prior to his injury and the invoices for the gardening expenses had been created by him. The defendant argued that the claim should be dismissed in accordance with Section 57.

The trial judge took the view that the dishonesty, while fundamental to the claim for gardening expenses, was not fundamental to the claim as a whole, so the entire claim was not contaminated. This decision went to appeal and was reversed. The High Court held that the claimant had been fundamentally dishonest in pursuing the gardening expenses and, in its view, “the fact that the greater part of the claim might be honest is neither here nor there”. The entire claim was dismissed.

What