By: 14 August 2023
Cerebral palsy case sheds light on critical issues in complex injury cases

The landmark court decision provides definitive answers to long-standing legal controversies in complex injury claims, offering guidance and clarity for future cases. 

In a significant legal development, the recent trial of CCC (represented by her mother and litigation friend MMM) against Sheffield Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust [2023] EWHC 1770 (KB) marks the first quantum-only Cerebral Palsy case to go to trial in over six years. The trial, heard by Mr Justice Ritchie, lasted ten days and delivered its judgment on 12 July 2023. This case is particularly noteworthy as it addresses crucial matters in clinical negligence practice. 

The claimant, CCC, born in February 2015 at Sheffield Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, suffered severe chronic partial hypoxic ischaemia during her birth, leading to Cerebral Palsy. The case, represented by James Drydale of Taylor Emmet (pictured) and Richard Baker KC and Sarah Edwards of 7 Bedford Row, delved into various pivotal aspects: 

  • Night time care: A central point of contention was the required night-time care for CCC. The debate centered on the need for one or two awake carers. Ultimately, the judge upheld the view of the claimant’s care expert, supported by CCC’s mother, case manager, deputy, and support worker, that two awake carers were necessary.