By: 26 April 2016
Diminution in value claims: Knowing the one head of loss rule

A dearth of Court of Appeal decisions in this area, coupled with a growth in diminution claim numbers, has led to a number of commonly held, but ultimately misconceived, views developing over diminution in value claims. Glyn Thompson looks at how to deal with them

Diminution – the extent to which a chattel suffers a reduction in value as a result of damage – has existed as a legitimate head of compensation for more than 125 years (see The Endeavour [1890] 6 Asp MC 511).

It is established law, for instance, that the loss arises immediately upon the damage occurring and irrespective of whether the damage is ever repaired. It seems surprising, therefore, that by the time Coles v Hetherton [2012] EWHC 1599 (Comm) got to the High Court people were still posing questions like – are diminution and repair the same thing?

Mr Justice Cooke answered that question unequivocally: there is no such thing as a claim for repairs and a claim for diminution, there is only diminution. Understanding what repair costs are (via estimates etc) serves only to give a marker for assessing what the reduction in value actually is.

When Coles v Hetherton got to the Court of Appeal Aikens LJ reaffirmed that using repairs as a point of reference is a practice that courts “should continue to follow” but that was it. There was no extension or expansion of diminution into two distinct heads of loss. Aikens LJ remarked that the reasonable cost of repairs “may not always represent the full amount of the diminution” because, alluding to Payton v Brooks [1974] 1 Lloyd’s Rep 241, some residual reduction in value may persist but he went no further.

If there was any doubt beforehand, the principle of ‘one head of loss’ was set solidly into law from Coles onwards and those faced with claims for repairs and diminution should look to bind them up as one and conclude such a single claim on a full and final basis.

Guidance from case law

Whilst the firmly established principles of diminution were forged out of Admiralty case law, Payton was the first and last Court of Appeal case (Coles aside) to look at diminution solely in relation to motor vehicle value reduction.

Practice Direction (Citation of Authorities) [2001] 1 W.L.R 1002 CA, dictates that county court decisions may not be cited in any court – so are of no use – unless they purport to (a) establish a new principle of law, or (b) extend the law as it existed before that decision.

However, decisions of District Judges are not binding upon their equivalents, so any new principles of law purportedly established with any given District Judge’s decision will not be binding. And what value is an unbinding principle?