By: 15 June 2016
Fundamental dishonesty: a claimant solicitor’s perspective

After Newcastle-based Winn Solicitors struck a significant blow against defendant insurers seeking to make allegations of fundamental dishonesty, legal director Ghazala Bashey discusses the impact of this ruling on claimants and claimant solicitors…

Since the introduction of the fundamental dishonesty principles, and particularly since Section 57 of the Criminal Justice and Courts Act 2015 came into force in April 2015, defendants have taken up the issue with zeal. Numerous cases have been heavily publicised in which some disingenuous claimants have been punished for bringing dishonest and exaggerated claims; however, amid the defendant-based fervour and enthusiasm for findings that offer them significant costs rewards, the fact that some claimants are wrongly and unfairly accused has been sadly lost. The recent case of Nesham v Sunrich Clothing Limited (unreported, 22 April 2016) may help to redress this balance.

In this instance, the defendant’s representatives sought to obtain a finding of fundamental dishonesty on appeal, simply because the claimant had failed to establish liability in a fast-track RTA case. In refusing permission to appeal, His Honour Judge Freedman’s judgement offers hope for claimants who are relentlessly and unfairly accused of being ‘fundamentally dishonest’.

The claimant in this case had been involved in an RTA in October 2014. Liability was disputed, as is the case in many RTA claims, and the matter ultimately proceeded to trial in January 2016 at North Shields County Court before District Judge Charnock-Neal. The claimant lost on liability.

The judge and counsel attending agreed that qualified one-way costs shifting (QOCS) applied to the case, which protected the claimant against paying the defendant costs. The introduction of QOCS implemented a recommendation of Lord Justice Jackson which was aimed at counter-balancing the impact on personal injury claimants of the decision to abolish recoverability of CFA success fees and, in particular, ATE insurance premiums.

It was at this late stage in the proceedings, however, that the defendant’s representatives, for the first time, sought to accuse Nesham of being a liar and claimed that he was ‘fundamentally dishonest’. The point had never been pleaded and was pursued as an attempt by the defendant’s representatives to recover costs.

DJ Charnock-Neal considered the submissions and held that the claimant “gave me his version of events. I have preferred not to accept that version, but it does not necessarily follow that he was fundamentally dishonest.”

The defendant had therefore failed in their attempts to secure a finding of dishonesty and, having been accused once of lying, Nesham thought that was the end of the matter – having walked away with no compensation but also with the protection afforded to him by QOCS; however, the defendant’s representatives did not stop there and instead lodged an appeal against the District Judge’s findings. If successful on appeal, the defendant’s representatives could potentially have established that a claimant who fails on liability in a straightforward case could almost automatically be found to be fundamentally dishonest and face a large costs order alongside potential criminal sanctions. This could have set an extremely dangerous precedent for all personal injury claimants.

Thankfully the claimant was in a position to have legal representation (a position that might not be the case if the small claims reforms proposed by the government are impleme