By: 12 January 2017
Allow pre-medical offers for certain claims, says Lloyd’s Market Association

The Lloyd’s Market Association (LMA) has called on the Government to permit pre-medical offers in certain circumstances as it digests responses to its consultation document on small PI claim reforms.

The LMA has said that it supports the vast majority of proposed reforms included in Reforming the Soft Tissue Injury (Whiplash) Claims Process, but wants to see pre-medical offers permitted in certain circumstances, such as where claims are presented more than six months after the accident. It says that a medico-legal report offers no benefit in such cases and only adds time and cost to the settlement process.

The Ministry of Justice (MoJ) is currently proposing to ban insurers from making settlement offers before a medical examination has been undertaken.

David Powell, LMA Non-Marine Manager, said: “At present it is extremely difficult for insurers to defend against unmeritorious soft-tissue claims. Diagnosis of soft-tissue injuries and any related pain and suffering is self-reported by claimants, often months after the accident. Doctors are incentivised to support the claimant and the resulting legal ‘evidence’ is almost impossible for insurers to challenge or disprove.

“A direct consequence is that costs for insurers have spiralled out of control, with claims now 50% higher than 10 years ago, despite a fall in accident frequency. Premiums will remain unnecessarily high unless we change the compensation system to remove incentives for middlemen and minimise abuses”.

However, the LMA’s thinking on pre-medical offers directly contradicts that of large sections of the claimant community.

In its response to the consultation, TRUE solicitors has said that any increase in the number of injury claims is due to an entirely dysfunctional motor insurance industry, which makes “epidemic numbers” of pre-medical offers to represented and unrepresented claimants.

“The number of injury claims is higher than a decade ago but the increase is a direct consequence of an entirely dysfunctional motor insurance industry,” said the firm.

“It is clear from the consultation paper that the insurance industry has been less than candid about its use of pre-medical offers […] the consultation document […] states ‘anecdotal evidence indicates that around 10% (in excess of 50,000 cases) of all RTA PI claims are currently settled without a medical assessment’.

“This figure is demonstrably wrong and ignores the thousands upon thousands of RTA injury claims that insurance companies capture and settle direct without medical evidence where the claimant is not represented.

TRUE goes on to say in its response that from 15 March to 16 April, its system recorded that it received pre-medical offers from insurance companies on 25.31% of all cases th