Insurers’ appeals against the business interruption test case brought by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) failed at the final hurdle this morning, with the Supreme Court backing policyholders whose Covid-19 claims were dismissed last year.
The Supreme Court upheld the High Court’s judgment in September that largely went in favour of policyholders who argued that insurers had failed to cover legitimate claims on business interruption policies arising from a pandemic.
The FCA filed the test case against eight insurers, after identifying their business interruption policy wordings as capturing the majority of the key issues that could be at dispute in the legal proceedings brought in response to rejections of Covid-19 claims.
Hearings took place in July, representing a rapid turnaround for a case of this scale, and the insurance industry has waited anxiously for the result.
Much of the litigation centered on business interruption policy add-ons, which covered losses resulting from any occurance of a notifiable disease within a specified geographical radius, typically 25 miles, of the insured premises.
Many insurers refused to honour policies when the UK entered lockdown in March 2020, arguing that they didn’t cover global pandemics.
The FCA argued for policyholders that the ‘disease’ and ‘prevention of access’ clauses in the representative sample of policy types provide cover in the circumstances of the coronavirus (Covid-19) pandemic, and that the trigger for cover caused policyholders’ losses.
The High Court’s judgment in September said that most of the disease clauses and certain prevention of access clauses provide cover and that the pandemic and the government and public response caused the business interruption losses.
Six insurers appealed against those conclusions for a number of the disputed policy types, but the Supreme Court dismissed those appeals, for different reasons from those of the High Court.
On the FCA’s appeal, the Supreme Court ruled that business interruption cover may be available for partial closure of premises and as full closure, and for mandatory closure orders that were not legally binding.
The Supreme Court also ruled that valid claims should not be reduced because the loss would have resulted in any event fro